4 Best Livebearers for Tropical Fish Hobbyists

Four of the popular species of livebearers – guppies, mollies, platys, and swordtails – compose a large percentage of the tropical fish hobbyist market today. This is due to a number of factors, including the fact that they are hardy, relatively peaceful, very colorful, and among the easiest fish to breed.

“Livebearer” describes any animal that bears its young life, instead of by laying eggs–in that way, even humans and most mammals are “livebearing” also. With cold-blooded animals such as fish, this is a rarer reproductive method used only by a small subset of fish. In addition to the four species described above, there are also rarer species (with regards to the tropical hobbyist field) that are livebearing. These include mosquitofish, which are native as far north as southern North America and are closely related to wild guppies, and more exotic “weird” and unrelated fish like the halfbeak and the four-eyed fish, Anableps.

This article will only focus on the “big four” since this is the large majority of what is encountered by beginners. This article will also not delve into the details of genetics, since I have just a few notes on the individual species and because their care and breeding are very similar between the species, I will have general livebearer comments at the bottom.

Best Livebearers for Hobbyists

The Guppy: Poecilia reticulata

Perhaps the most well-known tropical fish livebearer, the guppy today continues to be very popular among both beginners and advanced breeders. Today, there are hundreds of beautiful varieties, from lyretails to fantails coming in a rainbow of colors and patterns, seemingly only limited by the imagination (they were all originally developed from wild guppy strains, which show a great deal of variation in color and tail shape, as you may notice from the relatively dull-looking “feeder guppies” you see at the pet store). Because of all the intense breeding, however, most of the hardiness has been bred out of many strains of this species.

As a rule, the fancier the variety, the harder it is to raise it well. In fact, I would not recommend them for community tanks at all, as many seem more susceptible to disease lately. Their big tails seem like the perfect sites for infections to take hold. They are as a general rule, beautiful and peaceful little fish that can do best in small, species-only tanks or ones with just a few other species, such as a livebearer community tank. For more info specifically on guppies, read up on them at the International Fancy Guppy Association site.

The Molly: Poecilia schenops, Poecilia latipinna & Poecilia velifera

There are a number of different color, shapes, and fin varieties that have been bred today; they include the black molly (shown above), dalmation molly (white with black speckles), the silver molly (shown in some photos below under breeding), and a squat-bodied form called the balloon molly. All these breeds originated from the wild sailfin molly, P. latipinna, and all can also be bred to be long-finned. While it is true that most mollies prefer slightly alkaline water, and really are borderline brackish water fish that do best with a little sea salt, from my experience, they are also a highly adaptable and robust group. They are usually relatively peaceful fish, grazing on algae when they aren’t filling up their greedy little bellies, but sometimes a large female will turn into a bully of smaller fish.

The Platy: Xiphophorus maculatus

Very colorful and active fish, this kind of livebearers is bred into many popular varieties today. Some of the most common are coral (bright red all over), wagtail (deeper red with black fins), sunset (half orange fading into yellow), tuxedo (half orange and black abdomen), moon (iridescent pale blueish-green to violet), and the Mickey Mouse (yellow with a black Mickey Mouse pattern on the tail) platies. I have found them to do a great job of brightening up a drab tank, and their colors contrast well with a lush plant background, but many platies seem to be less hardy than older books will tell you they are (possibly due to excessive inbreeding). I have found some to be very susceptible to certain kinds of fungal and bacterial infections (specifically Columnaris; go to the disease page to read more on that). This is especially true if they are being harassed by breeding competition or other species of bullying fish.

The Swordtail: Xiphophorus helleri

The swordtail is extremely closely related to the platy, above, and in fact, they share the same genus name and will often hybridize. Care-wise, they really are not different at all, though some would say they have more sleek and torpedo-shaped bodies and thus have slightly more swimming room requirements. For the most part, the only major difference is just in appearance: male swordtails have a “sword” at the bottom of their caudal fin (tail), as seen above in the bottom fish.

General Care Comments

All these species are Central American/Yucatan (Mexican) species and relatively easy to keep. As a general rule, beginners should not concern themselves excessively with changing water values such as pH–though they naturally occur in bodies of water that are relatively alkaline (slightly above 7.0), they are adaptable species and will do best if you just keep their water quality high (by that I mean lack of pollution) but otherwise stable. This is done through regular water changes and watching out for overcrowding/overfeeding, just as with all fish. In general, a 10-gallon tank can support no more than 6-10 individual livebearers (depending on species–guppies being smaller, and sailfin mollies being larger) before you start getting into problems of overcrowding and disease.

All these species are top-feeding and will eat a wide variety of foods. Although they are not picky, they should have foods with high vegetable content, at least as an occasional supplement. You will notice that most will happily spend their lives roaming the upper levels of the tank seeking food (their up-turned mouths are well-adapted for this), grazing algae off of tank surfaces and decorations when the males are not busily chasing around females in an attempt to mate. For individuals that are not active and continually hide at the bottom or gasp at the surface, you should suspect ammonia poisoning, stress, and/or disease that results from any combination of the above. Depending on the circumstances, this may require water changes, a reevaluation of the tank environment/maintenance schedule, and separation of the sick fish into a hospital tank for treatment.

Sexing & Breeding Comments

Male livebearers are easily distinguished from females by the presence of a gonopodium, an anal fin modified into a point. This is illustrated below very clearly, in a male silver sailfin molly:

This is in contrast to the female anal fin, which is splayed out like a fan, like all her other fins. This female silver molly, shown below with some of her grown young, illustrates the difference:

Livebearers are also known as the “rabbits of the fish world” and will breed easily, even in a beginner’s tank. On occasion, you may notice some tiny movement in the gravel and find a pair of eyes (almost half the size of their body) staring back at you! Young fry should be siphoned out away from the hungry community tank occupants and raised separately on tiny foods such as baby brine shrimp, rotifers, mosquito midges, Drosophila larvae or Daphnia (livebearer fry are hardier and bigger when born, in general, than their egglayer counterparts, and will usually also take crumbled flake; sometimes they even survive in the community tank).

The water should be crystal clear and changed frequently, as babies are more delicate and die of disease and pollution at the drop of a hat, sometimes with no visible symptoms (they are so tiny!). Make sure that the filter has a sieve cover that prevents the tiny fry from getting sucked in, or just use a sponge filter, which is great for fry tanks because the flow is indirect and weak). It takes a little over a month before young grow to a size (bigger than ½ inch) where they can be readmitted into a community tank environment.

As one final note, please make sure you have enough room for all the babies if you attempt to breed them (or I should say, allow them to breed, since they will do so so easily). As with all pets, pet ownership is a responsibility; if you do not have the room for what may potentially end up being a large group (50-100!) of full-grown livebearers, then try and keep males and females separate. They can and will overpopulate their own tanks through their own breeding habits if given a chance, which can become a real problem once the young start to grow to full size. This will end up causing a total tank crash as they grow, and none of your fish can be maintained healthy in this sort of overpopulated environment.

Another alternative is a natural form of culling (killing off young quickly and painlessly)–just buy fish that you know will eat the young right away, such as tetras and danios (make sure you have enough room for THOSE and that they are compatible with the adults before purchasing!). Also, many times parents will cannibalize their own young shortly after birth, which is fine and preferable to letting them suffer in an overpopulated tank, but sometimes some will get away. If you truly are interested in raising them, then just make sure you have the means to either give them more room in a separate tank later or find them all good homes where they are wanted as they grow larger.

Related articles:

Building a Betta Friendly Community Tank

Aquarium & Fish Medication Dosing Made Easy

Top 15 Best Betta Tank Mates & Companions

Keeping Live Plants (Java Moss & Ferns) in Your Betta’s Tank